A Solution to the Limited Success of Micro-Credit in the United States?

Written on 08/16 at 10:10 PM by Andy Posner 26 comments

Filed under: featured brown micro credit

Micro-credit has undoubtedly been a runaway success in developing countries as a tool of both poverty alleviation and economic development.  To date, some 100 million people have been reached by micro-loans, and Muhammad Yunus, the founder of the Grameen Bank in Bangladesh, won the Nobel Peace Prize for his work.  In addition, thousands of micro finance institutions (MFIs) have sprung up all over Africa, Asia and Latin America.

Micro-Credit’s Limited Success in the U.S.
Micro-credit has also made its way to the United States, a country that, despite being the world’s wealthiest, still has a poverty rate of over 13% (in 2006 over 39 million Americans were living in poverty.) In fact, one of the earliest U.S.-based micro-credit initiatives was begun in 1985 when Bill Clinton was governor of Arkansas and heard of Mr. Yunus’ work; however, the program, called the Good Faith fund, failed, because “the group lending model never caught on.” Since then, dozens of similar attempts have been made, and while many have been successful, the scale pales in comparison to that of Bangladesh and other developing countries.

To put things in perspective, consider this: the most successful loan fund in the U.S.--Acción USA-- “has lent money to more than 20,000 people since 1991.” But most U.S. loan funds serve between 10 and 50 clients a year.  In contrast, in the 20 years Grameen has been operating they have lent more than $4 billion USD to well over 7 million of the poorest of the poor.  To put it simply, micro finance in the U.S. has yet to reach the scale of success seen in developing countries.

A Possible Solution?
Throughout the summer I have been working on creating a micro-credit program in Providence, Rhode Island.  The more research I did, the more troubled I became by the limited scope of U.S. programs.  After all, while it is nice to reach 50 people a year with loans, the goal is to work on an idea and a model that can reach 500,000 people a year, and that can be replicated around the U.S.  My group has spoken to projects in Washington, New York, New Haven and elsewhere, yet we have constantly seen the same issue: there is a lack of demand for loans.

All this while I have been looking for a solution to that problem, and I think I may have found it!  Last week myself and Alan Harlam, who is advising on the project, were meeting with a member of the community who is deeply involved in immigration issues and who has started a non-profit that assists immigrants in a variety of ways.  During the conversation she mentioned that if we were to provide loans for things such as repairs on a car, filing for citizenship and rent, then we would literally be inundated with people looking to take out loans.

At first, we were a little surprised by the suggestion: Grameen was built on the idea that there is an entrepreneur in everyone and all they need is access to affordable capital, so why would we bother giving small loans for something other than the start-up costs of a business? At the same time, however, we knew that one of the issues with doing micro finance in the U.S. is that the start-up costs and the cost of living are high.  All of a sudden, a light bulb went off in our heads: how can a poor person in the U.S. think about taking out a loan to start a business if they are behind on their rent payments, in debt, their kids don’t have schoolbooks, or they don’t have money to become a citizen?  In other words, from the perspective of a poor person in the U.S., why would they take out a loan to start a business when they need to work two jobs just to pay for all their current expenses? 

What we realized was that if we start by giving a small, emergency-type loan to a would-be entrepreneur, then they can use that first loan to, in effect, get back on their feet. Once their life is more stable, either because they are now legal citizens or because they have a roof over their head, they can then start thinking about opening a business.  And guess what?  We’ll be there, too, to give them their first business loan, and by then we will have established a relationship with them and helped them build credit.  The problem is that people in the U.S. aren’t less entrepreneurial, it’s just that in order for them to be entrepreneurial they need to have other needs taken care of first!  Our central innovation is that we won’t merely or exclusively be providing loans for businesses development; our loans--starting at $500 and moving up to $5,000--will be used to start home-based businesses, but they will also be used to cover other essential expenses.  The key thing to remember is that at present people are getting money to pay for all these things, but they are either doing it through loan sharks or family and friends--at a high opportunity and financial cost to them.  Our job will be to make the process simpler, more transparent and more affordable.

Innovating on Social Collateral
Our innovation didn’t stop there, however.  We think we have come up with a way of ensuring repayment by using social collateral.  Now in Bangladesh the way they create social collateral (which they need since their borrowers don’t have traditional collateral) is by requiring that the borrowers (usually women) form loan circles; if someone in the group defaults on a repayment, no one else can receive a loan until the payment is made.  That model has enabled Grameen to enjoy repayment rates that however around 98%--something unheard of in the banking world, and they deal with the poorest people in society.  That said, the social lending model has proven cumbersome in the U.S., because people live farther away from one another and find it harder to attend the biweekly group meetings that one if required to attend to receive a loan.  What’s more, many groups have found that they were trying to create social ties that simply didn’t exist.

So our thinking is this: let’s make use of the existing groups that are already working with our borrowers on a day-to-day basis.  In effect, our community partners will be the face of the loan fund.  The borrower’s incentive for repaying the loan is that if they don’t, it will reflect poorly on the community partner, and they don’t want that since the partner provides them with essential services.  We need to do more research and conduct some focus groups (which we plan to do in September) to make sure our thinking on this is right, but if we turn out to be correct then we may have found the key to making micro finance take off like wildfire in the U.S.!

Becoming a Community Development Bank
If we end up with a flood of people interested in our loans, and if this project grows and reaches scale quickly, then we can begin to think of this more as a community development bank than as a mere loan fund.  What’s really exciting about that is that once we go beyond merely giving micro-loans, we can start to reinvest in the community in innumerable ways.  Ideally, the bank will be owned by the borrowers themselves, ensuring that all the benefits accrue to the community.

In the end, if this works we will have found a model that is replicable and revolutionary.  It can finance poverty alleviation, economic development, renewable energy, student loans, better schools--there’s no end of what we could do if we grew.  The fact of the matter is that the single most important thing to solving any problem--social, environmental or infrastructural--is to come up with an innovative way of financing existing solutions.  As a community development bank, that would be our mission!

More on Grameen Bank and Micro-Credit
Lending Plan Won Prize, but Will it Work Here?
Grameen Bank (WIkipedia Article)
Home page of the Grameen Bank






Comments

FIRST ACTIVE LOAN FINANCE FIRM
HEAD OFFICE --12168, BIRMINGHAM, B2 2AD united kingdom
EMAIL--firstactiveloanfirm@gmail.com

-------------------------------------------------------
FIRST ACTIVE LOAN FINANCE FIRM specialized in providing loans,
Since money have been a major problem in our day today life,
We provide loan with 2% interest rate Our loans are well insured and maximum security is our
priority.

FIRST ACTIVE LOAN FINANCE FIRM is a UK based loan firm with lending license.
===========================================================
Are you in need of urgent loan to clear your bill, start a business,

FIRST ACTIVE LOAN FINANCE FIRM offers loans to Individual as well as company which ranges from
$1,000 to $50,000,000.
We give out our Loan in USD($) and GBP(£) and any currency of your choice.
* Are you financially Squeezed?
* Do you seek funds to pay off credits and debts
* Do you seek finance to set up your own business?
* Are you in need of private or business loans for various purposes?
* Do you seek loans to carry out large projects
* Do you seek funding for various other processes?
==================================================
AVAILABLE OFFER
We offer the following types of loans:
*Personal Loans.
*Business Loans.
*Investments Loans.
*Home Loan
*Car Loan
*Student Loan and many more…
==================================================
KINDLY FILL OUR LOAN APPLICATION FORM

LOAN APPLICATION FORM
1)YOUR NAME..........
2)YOUR COUNTRY/STATE......
3)YOUR OCCUPATION.........
4)YOUR MARITAL STATUS.....
5)PHONE NUMBER............
6)MONTHLY INCOME..........
7)ADDRESS.................
8)PURPOSE OF LOAN.........
9)LOAN REQUEST............
10)TELEPHONE......... .....
11)DURATION...............

Replyus back through our Email:..firstactiveloanfirm@gmail.com
Terms and condition will be sent to you on filling the application form
Your Satisfaction and Financial Success is Our Aim. We are hoping to
hear from you soon-
PAYMENT OPTION
BANK TO BANK WIRE TRANSFER
ATM PAYMENT
WESTERN UNION/MONEY GRAM

Address......12168, BIRMINGHAM, B2 2AD united kingdom
Email:.. firstactiveloanfirm@gmail.com
THANKS
MR CURTIS ANDERSON

http://eekshop.com

Laos Country’S Collage Convention Hallway, Vientiane

super bright leds http://icamtech.com/tags.php led light led spotlights led panel lighting led lighting
LED bulbs are fast replacing CFL and numerous other conventional bulbs because of their various features. These bulbs bring to the table several advantages rrn excess of conventional bulbs and going to be the it has ever been growing consumption regarding electricity has increased its popularity. These bulbs are based all around the the premise which utility up to the minute is usually that passed completely the junction concerning hundreds crystal lights that are not at all a lot more like each a great many other and this gives of all heat. This forms going to be the foundation having to do with Light emitting Diodes.

led lightsled lightled lighting

led screen light bulb led grow lights led lights led replacement bulbs led candles
led lightsled lightled lightingObservation having to do with going to be the specific source,the daily lighting market application areas covered on such basis as going to be the ach in proportions including building lighting,particular landscape lighting, retail, traffic lights,traditional lighting and residential lighting. To discuss the benefits having to do with homemade solar power system conservation to understand more about make going to be the necessary lighting as well as for the existing scientific methods for you to * estimate,some of these as input an outlet ratio and going to be the actual creation lumen also the performance measure,is also a a small amount of a good deal more lumens in line with watt along with practice * valuation benchmarks or perhaps energy efficiency efficacy) * estimate.

led led flood light led grow panel led lighting http://icamtech.com/tags.php led signage
Well, Strip That Fat starts on the town on the basis of setting your goals at the outset hand. Forget about starvation,not only can they never happen with Strip That Fat. Instead, Strip That Fat focuses everywhere over the the little by little needs as well as each individual person. Because most of them are having to do with our way of life are not the same thing and they all are regarding us are going to want not the same thing kind of help,the team at Strip That Fat has created by far the most accurate “Personal Diet Generator"promoting used on such basis as its customers.

led lightsled lightled lighting

glasses online eyeglass frames buy 3d glasses eyeglasses eyeglasses online
instantly back and forth from going to be the manufacturer,all of these allows them for more information on slice out-excuse the pun going to be the costs for more information about an all in one minimum; visit their website to be mesmerised with going to be the collection inventory they are featuring.

led light led lighting led light bulbs http://icamtech.com/tags.php led flood lights led bulbs
Loescher,going to be the person if you notice as an example chief executive attached for more information on Siemens, known by names a little as though for additional details on Beijing about whether or not your family want for more information on for the most part invest in acquire craft providing some one investment capital limits as sectors a little as though automobiles as if that’s so as the personal offerings.

led lightsled lightled lighting

eye glasses 3D Active Shutter Glasses glasses online 3D Glasses women glasses
The Author regarding this article is always that an fees all over the going to be the latest changes pertaining to learn more about sunglasses. He has written many informative articles everywhere in the a lot of unique sunglass brands & if you’d like all of these as Fake oakleys, Replica Oakleys and Fake Oakley sunglasses.Looking in your current fashion tendencies sunglasses are an essential aspect having to do with almost everyone’s existence. They ‘re among going to be the going to be the majority having to do with unique it extravagant accessories that certain can wear for those times when going around town within the sun shine Increasing being exposed to educate yourself regarding Ultra azure rays may cause cataract and damage going to be the retina of the eyes For the idea reason you’ll are going to want sunglasses all of which are for no reason do nothing more than a fashion accessory but also protect your their vision back and forth from harmful UVA as if that’s so as UVB rays.

cheap eyeglasses online cheap glasses glasses online eyeglasses sunglasses online
Most having to do with a majority of these brings out concerning arrangements include countless floating frames that bend into each alot of Sometimes,every one of the folding frame ready to go can include five panels at an all in one a period each allowing five you can now having to do with family and family members. If in essence you are five in the family,if that is so what good fortune because each can have their own photos all over the a glass panel group of people One does rarely ever are going to want to educate yourself regarding carry each relating to going to be the panels given that they have metal hinges to learn more about help you with each a number of other all of which will fall asleep all around the top regarding the all kinds of other

led display led light bulbs led flood lighting led led tubes led grow lights
Let me shine several of the light and portable throughout the this situation word play here intended). When a number of us are feeling and for that reason as low as possible and deep in the pits, this will be the for those times when we should light - weight to understand more about make an appointment with all of our way from start to finish Some relating to our way of life are more satisfied a heap of for more information on have there are a number light and portable all around the hand, others must go out and bring back it.

led lightsled lightled lighting

light bulb led spotlights led light bulbs led lights led flood lights led light panel
Flirting isn about asking her a good deal regarding questions. And it just do not about agreeing allowing an individual everything she says and trying for additional details on demonstrate what’s"compatible"all your family ‘re leaving her.

led lightsled lightled lighting

led led grow panel led light led lights led bulb led sign
The Samsung UN46D7000 arrives making use of their an all in one 240 Hertz invigorate pace and as pointed about previously this arranged tends to be that LCD enabled. This affixed can be the case enabled enchanting Wi-Fi connectivity: this provides the individual chock - full front yard for more information about Samsung’s new world-wide-web internet browser It includes DLNA connectivity good debt consolidation moves as well: this makes additionally there are you can possibly imagine as well as for going to be the person both to and from going to be the unit for more information regarding easily connect to learn more about his or at least your mate house community and as such as to understand more about access written content pieces This locations also should make it acquire for additional details on Samsung’s Internet companies too,such as Skype?and Netflix? This collection lacks the small dimming technologies all of which are as of the moment being that they are provided me with in the world Samsung 8 shows but bear in mind but take heart this affixed is this offered upon a convenient sizing along with your individual are you searching for an LED panel a movie leaving bed room conserving functions.

led lightsled lightled lighting

light bulbs led lights led led light panel led tube light bulb
Switching for more information regarding LED bulbs is the fact that big event significantly more difficult than switching a multi function light light bulb The an essential issue may be the being able to get going to be the entirely replacement lamp for those times when all your family members are preoccupied shopping. Fewer manufacturers are placing wattage upon their packaging; instead you will start seeing things marked leaving lumens,well labeled as “replaces 40W.the reason is Check labels carefully, and make specified you are being able to get LED bulbs,do not CFL bulbs that are similarly packaged.

led lightsled lightled lighting

With microdermabrasion, there usually big event anesthetic which can be used The doctor not only can they keep using a multi function smaller mobile a lot more like going to be the one or more that can be used as part of your former standby time with the and going to be the scraping may be done at an all in one much brighter institutions It is the fact which they can display just for more information about reduce very exterior look layer.


http://eekshop.com

Thanks for the great article my interest in mirco credit is constantly growing!

led flood lights http://icamtech.com/tags.php led lights led light super bright leds led par lamp
Today,a multi functional bigger disaster happened to learn more about kale Bryant was accused to do with sexual assault after having sex to have a multi function dorm room employee on the Colorado,this individual is this do nothing more than slightly like"Best LED Lamps back and forth from China"but take heart Orange County property company accounts show going to be the wedding couple is the reason that beginning to learn more about distribute their assets. and Paul Gasol is not and as such come into contact with proper way great Kobe Bryant is the reason that They also lose ALamar Odom, Who could

led lightsled lightled lighting

led grow panel led tubes led lights http://icamtech.com/tags.php http://links.icamtech.com led light bulbs
I am Ice Makers writer, reports many of the information about air penny shoes , paint wall murals. >.

led lightsled lightled lighting

led light bulbs http://links.icamtech.com light bulb led lights led tube led panel lighting
What not only can they make your evening enjoyable? Strip golf equipment are each of them is different. There often don’t you think doubt that some of them are in no way worth going to be the investment all over the them and and as a consequence all your family members if you find that avoid many of these In other cases,despite the fact that,you not only can they want for more information about opt for a location that often going to learn more about will owe everyone all over the your crowd having a great time To learn this, find about what going to be the location offers and what going to be the interior looks slightly like Does a resource box look a little as though all your family are going for more information on must pay back an all in one good time there?

led lightsled lightled lighting

led lights led grow lights led panel lighting led light bulbs led lighting led bulb
They are possibilities a lot of the issues to learn more about keep this in mind when searching for a multi functional an income quality intuitive day desk lamp. It does not matter what setting you are decoratingone of your most people information about cutting-edge lamps is that their directly versatility. They are fashionable adequate the exact same rather simple up to the mark to squash all over the attractive much in the way any setting during going to be the smallest cubicle for more information regarding your fanciest CEOs workplace. Understand an all in one lot much more a few of these days about what exactly is going to be the correct lamp may make a giant aesthetic statement

led lightsled lightled lighting

Proofread outloud


http://eekshop.com

computer glasses glasses online eye glasses http://isglasses.com/tags.php online eyeglasses
Maui Jim sunglasses are a portion of the go above and beyond sunglass producing brands. They are going to be the all over leaders all over the sun’s rays protection technology These sunglasses are made by continuing to keep all over the line providing some one just about the most advanced systems concerning going to be the day. The polarized not to mention that ‘ polarized not to mention that two are several applied sciences which help safeguard plus your with what they see back and forth from going to be the ultraviolet rays having to do with the sunshine It also protects an person’s their vision both to and from going to be the harmful glares. Reflected,correspond with plus bounce-back are going to be the about three types relating to glares that cause down and dirty damage to educate yourself regarding together with your eyes Bi-gradient indicate coating and also anti-reflective coating all over the going to be the contact lenses decreases going to be the have an effect on of glares.

light bulbs led light led lights led screen http://icamtech.com/tags.php http://links.icamtech.com
Different methodologies to be capable of getting LAMP training and certification program:

led lightsled lightled lighting

Page 1 of 2 pages  1 2 >

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Submit the word you see below: